Appalachian History Series
Why Ivy Mountain Mattered
In the fall of 1861, both armies probed Kentucky’s mountains for advantage. The Big Sandy valley offered a workable corridor between Virginia and the Bluegrass. Confederate recruiters under Colonel John S. Williams gathered men around Prestonsburg and Pikeville, while the Union sent Brigadier General William “Bull” Nelson to shut that effort down and secure the eastern counties. The brief but sharp fight at Ivy Mountain helped end the first phase of the contest for the valley and steadied Union control in the region that winter.
The Opposing Forces
Union: Nelson’s column consisted of Ohio and Kentucky troops marching up the state road toward Pikeville. His report lists the 2nd, 21st, and 59th Ohio, a battalion of Kentucky volunteers under Colonel Charles A. Marshall, and sections of Captain P. W. Konkle’s Battery D, 1st Ohio Light Artillery. A separate detachment under Colonel Joshua W. Sill moved on a different road to cut off the Confederates near town.
Confederate: Williams oversaw a small, poorly supplied force in the hills. Companies from the 5th Kentucky Infantry and the 1st Kentucky Mounted Rifles, many newly recruited and carrying shotguns or hunting rifles, manned the ambush ground near Ivy Creek. Williams later admitted he had about 300 men in the action, with little ammunition on hand.
Into the Narrows, November 8, 1861
Nelson’s column entered a narrow defile where the state road hugs the river and then curls in a tight elbow at Ivy Creek. Confederate riflemen had concealed themselves along the ridge above the bend. When the head of Marshall’s Kentuckians reached the turn, a volley crashed out, killing four and wounding thirteen. Nelson threw in the 2nd and 21st Ohio on the slopes and unlimbered two guns in the road. After about an hour and twenty minutes of hard climbing and scattered fire, the Confederates broke and withdrew, leaving prisoners and wounded behind. Nelson recorded six Union killed and twenty-four wounded.
Pikeville Secured
Rain set in that night. The Confederates felled trees, burned bridges, and retreated toward Virginia. Nelson bivouacked beyond Ivy Creek, then entered Pikeville on the morning of November 10, where he found Sill already in possession after skirmishing with the rear guard. The Confederate column slipped into southwestern Virginia, ending the immediate threat in the Big Sandy.
What the Primary Sources Say
Nelson’s after-action report from “Camp Hopeless Chase, Piketon” gives the best terrain and casualty detail for the Union side, including his description of the elbow in the road, the ambush, and the climb up both ridges. He reported six killed and twenty-four wounded, and he believed thirty-two Confederate dead were found later along the route.
Williams’s report the next day struck a different tone. He wrote that the engagement lasted “about four hours,” that he had roughly 300 men, and that his loss was “10 killed and 7 or 8 wounded,” while claiming the Federals suffered far more. Whatever the exact totals, Williams conceded that superior Union numbers forced his withdrawal, which matches the operational outcome.
Strategic Significance
Although not a large battle, Ivy Mountain tipped the Big Sandy campaign toward the Union. The clash blunted Confederate recruiting in eastern Kentucky and opened the way for subsequent Union operations that winter, including Garfield’s January 1862 push that drove remaining Confederate forces from the area. National Park Service summaries frame Ivy Mountain as the fight that ended the first phase of the Big Sandy struggle.
Visiting the Ground Today
Travelers along US-23 near the mouth of Ivy Creek can stop at the Ivy Mountain monument, a fifteen-foot granite obelisk with wayside panels that interpret the action. Kentucky’s historical marker program identifies the site as the first important Civil War engagement in the Big Sandy valley, noting the Confederate force under Captain Andrew J. May and the Union troops under General Nelson.
Sources and Further Reading
United States War Department, The War of the Rebellion: A Compilation of the Official Records of the Union and Confederate Armies, Series I, Vol. 4. Report of Brig. Gen. William Nelson, “Camp Hopeless Chase, Piketon, Ky., November 10, 1861,” pp. 225-226. The Portal to Texas History+1
United States War Department, The War of the Rebellion, Series I, Vol. 4. Report of Col. John S. Williams, “Piketon, Ky., November 9, 1861,” p. 227. The Portal to Texas History
Colonel Joshua W. Sill to Nelson, Pikeville, November 10, 1861, Official Records, Series I, Vol. 4, p. 227. The Portal to Texas History
National Park Service, “Battle Detail, Ivy Mountain (KY003),” summary of the action and its outcome in the Big Sandy valley. National Park Service
Pike County Historical Society, “Wholly Ignorant of Our Presence,” local narrative and soldier letters that illuminate the approach to the ambush site. Pike County Historical Society
Kentucky Historical Society, Marker No. 164, “Battle of Ivy Mountain,” overview of the engagement and location. history.ky.gov
Historical Marker Database entries for the Ivy Mountain monument and text panels. HMDB+1
American Battlefield Trust, “Visit Ivy Mountain,” orientation to the site and summary significance.
Author Note [Blank]